Federal judge rules Maine school district cannot block church rental over traditional views on marriage and abortion
Court finds Hermon School Committee showed unlawful animus against The Pines Church when denying a year-long lease for Sunday services.
By Nikolai Witoszynski3 min read
WORLD is a news organization producing Biblically sound, daily coverage of global, national, and cultural current events. Photo: WORLD (aguardando autorização)
A U.S. federal court ruled that a Maine public school board violated the Constitution when it refused to grant a long-term lease to an evangelical church due to its conservative theological beliefs. Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker ruled that the Hermon School Committee violated the First Amendment by rejecting a long-term lease for The Pines Church.
The legal dispute began in 2022 when The Pines Church, a nondenominational congregation founded by Pastor Matt Gioia in the Bangor area, sought to rent space at Hermon High School for its Sunday morning services. As the congregation grew, leadership requested a six-month or one-year lease to provide stability for its weekly gatherings.
During public meetings and deliberations, school board members subjected the pastor to targeted questions regarding the church's positions on same-sex marriage, abortion, and diversity initiatives. Other community groups renting the school facility had never been asked to answer questions about their ideological or religious convictions.
Following the questioning, the committee voted 4-1 against approving a long-term contract, offering only a month-to-month arrangement. In his decision from the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine, Judge Walker noted that at least three of the five school board members displayed discriminatory animus toward the congregation's theological stance.
In his written opinion, Judge Walker underscored the legal requirement for state neutrality toward religious groups. If a public school’s facilities are available for public use, a religious organization cannot be denied access to those facilities because it is a religious organization, the judge wrote.
The court observed that board members disregarded legal advice provided by their own attorneys prior to the vote, who had warned them regarding First Amendment protections. In addition to First Amendment violations, the court concluded the board likely violated the Maine Human Rights Act by using the church's religious status as a substantial factor in its decision.
Implications for religious freedom across the United States
Although the court found in favor of the church regarding constitutional and state law violations, the judge did not order the school district to execute the requested long-term lease. The court awarded nominal damages of $1 to the church and allowed its legal counsel to submit a claim for attorneys' fees and costs.
Legal counsel from Advocates for Faith & Freedom, representing the congregation, praised the ruling as an important validation of religious liberty. They emphasized that public schools opening facilities to secular community organizations cannot legally exclude churches simply because of their Christian worldview.
The Hermon School Department stated in a public message that it is reviewing the court order to ensure compliance and determine whether internal facility use policies require revision.
From a movie theater to permanent building renovations
The journey of The Pines Church highlights the experience of church planting in New England. The congregation was established in 2021 inside a movie theater in Orono, growing to roughly 150 weekly attendees.
After access to the high school facilities was denied, the church continued gathering at Spotlight Cinemas while raising funds to secure a permanent home. According to updates on The Pines Church website, the ministry purchased a commercial building in Bangor and has been conducting extensive structural renovations, including foundation reinforcement, exterior insulation, and electrical upgrades.
The congregation's persistence aligns with the biblical encouragement in Galatians 6:9 to avoid growing weary while doing good. Throughout four years of administrative delays and court litigation, the leadership maintained regular ministry operations.
Attorneys for the church celebrated the ruling as a key precedent preventing local governments from barring religious groups from public spaces. The decision clarifies that theological disagreements do not grant public institutions authority to infringe upon constitutional rights.
The Herald covers what almost no one else does: the persecuted church, the discovery that confirms the Bible, the faith that never makes the evening news. No subscription, no paywall, no outside advertisers. If this story mattered to you, help the next one get written.